Concert reviews

Our new review concerns a concert that, thanks to television, we didn’t miss altogether. It was the world premier of ‘Requiem voor Ausschwitz’ by Roger Moreno Rathgeb, a Dutch componist, who composed his grand work in memory of the Roma and Sinti victims and all other victims of work camps during WWII for the occasion of this year’s Dodenherkenning. This is the national holiday in the Netherlands in memory of the end of WWII for the country and of all its victims on May 4th. The world premier for the Requiem took place in the Nieuwe Kerk in Amsterdam on May 3rd and the concert was broadcast the following night. It can be heard again at this web-address:

The performers were the Roma- and Sinti Philharmonics of Frankfurt am Main, conducted by Riccardo M. Sahiti, with the Amsterdams Studenten Koor and soprano Kristina Bitenc, alto Kadri Tegelmann, tenor Gevorg Hakobjan and bass Laurent Deleuil.

The Requiem is a one-hour piece composed according to classical traditions. At the premier, each traditional part was separated by readings from the memoirs or letters of Dutch Roma or Sinti victims of the work camps while photos of lots of victims were shown on computer screens around the orchestra. The whole event had a very serious atmosphere suited to the occasion of remembrance.

The music was also fully suited to the occasion. It is far from forced, modernistic styles, rather follows the musical language of hundreds of years of religious musical traditions in the footsteps of Brahms or Verdi. It may not be the work of a genius, but it is a very decent piece, understandable and ‘enjoyable’ in fitting ways. The flow of the music is natural and pleasing, but there is not such a great variety of themes and feelings, the dramatic high points are not very strong, but at least not bombastic. The basic tone is naturally of sorrow, but with a long piece as this, we would expect a wider range of motifs from sadness to tragedy. It is not a very exciting piece, let alone a really shocking one. But it is definitely the kind that leaves one’s mind to return to peace at the end, leaves the believers to return to their trust in their maker’s will.

The musicians did a decent job, the orchestra and the choir did what they were made to do and the soloists also performed well. Within the group of soloists we felt some difference of quality to the extent that we felt the soprano good, but the alto was lacking of power and colour mainly in her lower range. We felt the tenor provided the strongest and best quality performance, although none of them showed special colour of voice or real dramatic power.


The latest concert we have attended was part of the piano series in Arnhem. The guest performer on 1st March 2012, Rumanian pianist Radu Lupu filled the Musis Sacrum, and we believe very few of the audience, if any, left without feelings of elation at the music they heard.

The concert started with Schubert’s four impromtus Op.142. I have never heard the first impromtu, in c-minor, at such a slow pace, still, it worked magically. The concert really fired up after the second piece: the variations in the G-flat piece shone in their full beauty, and so did the final piece.

For me, Cesar Frank’s majestic  Prelude, Chorale and Fugue was a revelation. This piece is rarely played in concert and by radio channels either. We were very grateful for the inclusion that night. Radu Lupu showed all the brilliance, colour and finesse of this rare piece.

The second half of the concert included the Sonata in B-flat major (D.960). This great piece sounded altogether like magic under the hands of the pianist. No wonder this time that the audience applauded the pianist rising to their feet, and were treated by one of the Moment Musicaux in response to round off the concert. An unforgettable concert at that.

Earlier concerts

After an earlier concert, our criticism concerns American pianist Stephen Kovacevich (also known as Stephen Bishop), who performed in the Musis Sacrum in Arnhem on December 10th 2011. Two friends went to listen to him on that evening with high expectations, but, unfortunately, left dissatisfied.

The pianist performed Beethoven’s Op.10/1 Sonate in c, the nr.4 Partita (BWV 828) by J.S.Bach and Schubert’s nr.21 Sonate, but their impression was as if the concert consisted of only pieces by Bach. The artist’s rendering of the different pieces lacked colour and emotion, while his Bach also lacked the necessary clarity of expression and even precision of tempo. The pianist’s performance on that evening lacked credibility.

They found it a sorry sight that such a famed pianist may encounter such a dreary patch at a concert. They also found it unfortunate that they vitnessed his bad day.

Our following critique is a translation of the opinion of a couple of our friends who went to the Opera House in Budapest to see Rigoletto on 10th Nov. 2011.

The interior of the Opera House in Budapest.
Image via Wikipedia

Unfortunately, they came away with a feeling that could at best be described as mixed. Initially, they found the choir and singers really bored, lazy and unenthusiastic, the singing and movement disorganized. This may not have been true for all singers, as, for example, Kertesi Ingrid received praise for her voice and charm. Unfortunately, they felt her to be a bit over-age for her role, which somewhat disturbed the joy of listening to her.

After the interval, the troupe seemed to be revitalized, very possibly by the scolding they must have received by the director. Even so, the impression was of a level that we were not accustomed to a few decades ago. There seem to be a lack of young, up-coming local talent available as they referred to an earlier performance of Madama Butterfly, in which the image of Pinkerton was distorted by the seriously overweight 70-year-old singer in the role. As can be seen in our presentation of the programme in Budapest, there are several guest singers with various productions. Although Russian singers have a very good reputation, just like Hungarian singers, those coming to sing in Budapest may not belong to the top.

We must express our regret that Hungary is not capable of luring and keeping the best that are so professionally brought up there, or would like and are able to sing at the best opera houses.

Lots of great piano concerts can be heard the world over, whether live, or on CD’s, or on the internet, but rarely are we exposed to such an overwhelming impression of intense emotions and power as at the concert on the evening of 1st October 2011 at the Musis Sacrum in Arnhem. That night, we were fortunate to attend the first concert in the local series “Meesters van het klavier”, which was given by one of the most promising young pianists of our generation, Denis Kozhukhin, Russian pianist, winner of several competitions, the latest of which was the first prize of the prestigious Queen Elizabeth Concours in Brussels in 2010.

I personally am not a fan of Haydn’s piano sonatas, but with the warm, romantic feelings added to the classical precision, the performer won me over. The playful humanity of Haydn was shining brightly with intimacy this time.

From then on, Denis Kozhukhin blew away any doubts that he is already one of the greats. His performance combined power with softness, technical brilliance with the whole spectrum of human feelings, showing all variation between soft tranquilty and explosive passion in Brahms’ first sonata and the seven pieces he chose from the “12 Études d’exécution transcendante’ by Liszt. He performed without any extravaganza, but let the audience witness the highest quality of music-making. His simplicity of demeanor underlined his concentration on the best in all music.

His performance was never rushed. Instead, we had the impression that he often preferred to stay on the slow side of possibilities without giving up anything from brilliance. His forming the musical archs of thought was clear and spaced out, letting the audience contemplate between what has been and what is coming. And while many young performers would choose bravura pieces for encore, he chose a slow, song-like prelude from Bach’s Wohltemperierte Clavier and Busoni’s beautiful transcription of a Bach chorale. A devotee of the highest quality in music.

Whether he will really become one of the greatest of the greats is to be seen, but he has definitely enchanted his audience at the concert hall in the manner of his predecessors at the Queen Elizabeth: Gilels, Ashkenazy, Lazar Berman, Malcolm Frager, Mogilevsky, Nikolai Petrov, Anton Kuerti, or Ekaterina Novitskaya. We wish him all the best. We’d like to listen to him live for lots of years coming.

Our first concert for this site

On 14th March 2011 we took part in a fabulous concert at the Musis Sacrum in Arnhem, the Netherlands, which many of you may be sorry to have missed. One of the best Hungarian pianists for the last couple of decades, Zoltán Kocsis, accompanied rising international star violinist from Hungary, Barnabás Kelemen.

The concert started with Debussi’s Sonate in g in excellent taste. It was followed by perhaps the most outstanding performance of the first violin sonata by Bartók that I’ve ever heard for decades. The duo played high drama with shocking force and clarity, and proved, at least for me, that Kocsis is the best Bartók performer of our time, and that Kelemen’s rising international fame is highly deserved – his talent and musical understanding matches the doubtless greatness of Kocsis.
After the interval, an beautiful performance of Beethoven’s Kreutzer Sonata capped a magical evening.
If any of you could find an opportunity the listen to a concert by these two great musicians, try not to miss it. We highly recommend them to the connoisseur.

1 comment
  1. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: